Why don't some Shia celebrate Eid UL Fitr and Eid Al Azha?

Some Shia celebrate Eid UL Fitr and Eid Al Azha: All Muslims celebrate Eid ul Adha and Eid ul Fitr; they are the only festivals sanctioned in the Quran, and as a result everyone regardless of denomination celebrates it.

Contents

Why don’t some Shia celebrate Eid UL Fitr and Eid Al Azha?Do Shias and Sunnis celebrate Eid-ul-Fitr on different days?Why do Sunni and Shia Muslims break fast at different times?Why do Shias celebrate Nowruz and Sunnis only celebrate Eid?What is the similarity between Eid Ul Fitr and Eid Ul Adha?How do people typically celebrate Eid-al-Fitr?Read Also

Additionally, many Shias also celebrate…

Eid ul Ghadeer (only Shias)

Eid ul Mubahala (only Shias)

Mawlid (most Sunnis and Shias)

Eid e Nowruz (Shias and Sunnis in greater Persia)

Imamat day (Aga Khanis)

And… Salgirah Khushiali (Aga Khanis)

Why don’t some Shia celebrate Eid UL Fitr and Eid Al Azha?

All Muslims are commanded to celebrate Eid al Adha and Eid ul Fitr. Anyone who doesn’t is hardly a Muslim, as they are going against the command of Allah. The Prophet narrated that when he went to Madeenah, Allah commanded him to tell the people there that two festivals – Eid ul Fitr and Adha – were given to them by Allah to celebrate.

Every Shia celebrates both Eids. Shias fast pay zakat,go on Hajj so Shias do everything Prophet MUHAMMAD SAWW told us to do

Don’t believe in everything Mullas tell you.

instead of asking questions here, I would request you to go through books and find everything you need to know. There is no major difference between Shia and Sunni on Fiqh bases.

In summary, Eid is celebrated by ALL Muslims across the world! It is the most important festival known to Muslims, so Eid-ul-Fitr (celebrated post the holy month of Ramadan) and Eid-ul-Zuha (Bakrid) are occasions of great pomp and show and most importantly, piousness and sacredness for every Muslim, regardless of their so-called ‘sect,’ which in my view, is simply over-hyped! I can say this because I had family on both sides and although there were minute differences, when it comes to Allah, His Prophet, Qur’an, and Islam in general — Everything is very much alike! So, Sunnis and Shias celebrate EID!

Why don’t some Shia celebrate Eid UL Fitr and Eid Al Azha?

Do Shias and Sunnis celebrate Eid-ul-Fitr on different days?

Shia Muslims around the globe celebrate Eid Ghadīr on the 18th day of the final month of the Muslim lunar calendar (Dhu-ʾl-ḥijja) to commemorate a core element of Prophet Muḥammad’s divine message.

Moon sighting defines the day of Eid-ul-Fitr and Eid-ul-Adha. The moon can be sighted after 20 hours of its birth. This effect is visible in Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran, the Middle East & Saudi Arabia region. Variation of moon sightings in these countries does not depend upon Shias & Sunny etc.

Countries in the East up to India and in the West after Saudi Arabia celebrate Eid on the same day.

Why do Sunni and Shia Muslims break fast at different times?

They don’t do it at different times, they do it at different moments. There’s a difference.

The difference is in the interpretation of sunset. All Muslims break their fasts at sunset. But when exactly is sunset?

The modern scientific definition is when the sun goes down the horizon at the equator. That’s what the Shia observe. The literalist, older tradition, is when the sun is no longer visible and it starts to get dark. That’s what most Sunnis observe. They both do it at sunset. This sunset is the same moment in a flat country around the equator, but vastly different (about 30 minutes) in a mountainous country far from the equator.

Why do Shias celebrate Nowruz and Sunnis only celebrate Eid?

To begin with, your question itself is based on false information.

My mom is an Iranian Shia and my dad is an Arab Sunni. Contrasting backgrounds? Pretty much. But my upbringing made me feel that these two sects are not so different unlike what the world educated me with on growing up.

Anyways, your question is flawed! How?

Navroz is predominantly an Irani festival. Period. So, the other Shias across the world including those in Iraq, Syria, India, Pakistan, or elsewhere, Do NOT celebrate Navroz.

For your information, Navroz is the Irani New Year, so why would any other country’s citizens celebrate that day? It’s like saying Nepal should celebrate India’s Independence Day on 15th August since several Hindus reside in Nepal as well. Got the drift?

In an attempt to educate you further, the Parsi community that hails from Iran (the Birthplace of Zoroastrianism) too celebrates Navroz. If you’re an Indian and are remotely familiar with Indian Parsis, you’d know this fact.

2. Eid is celebrated by ALL Muslims across the world! It is the most important festival known to Muslims, so Eid-ul-Fitr (celebrated post the holy month of Ramadan) and Eid-ul-Zuha (Bakrid) are occasions of great pomp and show and most importantly, piousness and sacredness for every Muslim, regardless of their so-called ‘sect,’ which in my view, is simply over-hyped! I can say this because I had family on both sides and although there were minute differences, when it comes to Allah, His Prophet, the Qur’an, and Islam in general — Everything is very much alike! So, Sunnis and Shias celebrate EID!

What is the similarity between Eid Ul Fitr and Eid Ul Adha?

The prayer is the same, just the prayer intention that different. Some Family has the same routine like asking forgiveness each other, and also the food prepared is sometimes also the same. in my country it was “ketupat” (rice cake in square shaped) with “Opor Ayam” (Chicken soup with Coconut milk) and Rendang.

Both days are celebrated by the command of Allah to seek the pleasure of Allah.
Believers thank Allah; for completing the Fast in Ramadan on Eidul Fitr and for accepting an animal as sacrifice instead of son – on Eidul Adha.
Celebration of both days starts by offering Eid prayers.
Most of the traditions are common on both days; taking a shower, wearing the best clothes, using fragrance, visiting loved ones, etc.

How do people typically celebrate Eid-al-Fitr?

Eid al-Fitr is a major Islamic holiday that marks the end of Ramadan, the month-long period of fasting and spiritual reflection. The celebration of Eid al-Fitr varies from country to country and culture to culture, but there are certain customs and traditions that are observed by Muslims around the world. Here are some examples:

1. Prayer: Muslims typically start the day with a special Eid prayer, which is performed in a large congregation at a mosque or an open field.

2. Greeting: People greet each other with the Arabic phrase “Eid Mubarak,” which means “blessed Eid.”

3. Food: Eid al-Fitr is a time for feasting and sharing meals with family and friends. Special dishes are prepared, and it is customary to give food to the poor and needy.

4. Gifts: It is common to exchange gifts and money with family and friends, especially children.

5. Clothing: Muslims often wear new or traditional clothing on Eid al-Fitr, as a symbol of renewal and celebration.

6. Charity: Many Muslims donate to charitable causes during Eid al-Fitr, as a way of giving back to their communities.

7. Visiting: It is also common to visit family and friends during Eid al-Fitr, and to host open houses or gatherings.

Overall, Eid al-Fitr is a joyous occasion that brings together families and communities, and is celebrated with prayers, food, gifts, and acts of charity.